Aristotle Mill on Capital Punishment - 1322 Words

Aristotle amp; Mill’s Opinion on Capital Punishment Brianna Lelli Hugh Miller Paper #2 Topic #4 October 17th 2011 Capital Punishment is a moral controversy in today’s society. It is the judicial execution of criminals judged guilty of capital offenses by the state, or in other words, the death penalty. The first established death penalty laws can date back to the Eighteenth Century B.C. and the ethical debates towards this issue have existed just as long. There is a constant pro-con debate about this issue, and philosophers like Aristotle and Mill have their own take on this controversy as well. Aristotle is against capital punishment, while Mill believes it is morally permissible. Let me start off†¦show more content†¦Mill has an â€Å"eye for an eye and a tooth for a tooth† standpoint. If a person commits a terrible crime, they are nowhere near reaching a desirable end, nor do they have capacity to be virtuous, as Aristotle would say. If somebody is guilty of murder, then life in jail is too mild of a punishment for the crime he committed. It goes the other way around to o. If somebody is guilty of theft, then life in jail may be too hard of a punishment for that particular crime. Mill believes the only efficient punishment is one that is exactly equal to the crime. He doesn’t think a murderer should be allowed to live on with the potential to murder again. Another thing Mill focuses on is general responses among a society. He believes the only way to find desirable pleasure is to ask people and get a general response. So if you asked the family of a murder victim what they would like to see happen to the murderer, a probable general response would be to have him sentenced to death as well, and that is exactly what should happen. We know that Aristotle wouldShow MoreRelatedMoral Theories Of Utilitarianism And Deontological Ethics1266 Words   |  6 Pagesjustifying moral principles. Utilitarianism has been clarified by Jeremy Bentham (1748-1832) and John Stuart Mill (1806-1873). Bentham proposed that actions are based upon the consequences ( Moreland, 2009), and ongoing work on his theory will help in providing grounds for legal actions. His ideas regarding every human keeping his interests above the interests of others, were further worked by Mill (Sweet, n.d). Utilitarianism tries to improve the moral state of the world for as many people as possibleRead MoreRacism - A History : The Color Of Money1063 Words   |  5 Pageseconomics served as the driving force behind slavery. The documentary highlights that although slavery existed for several centuries prior to the slave trade, the concept of racism is rooted in the enslavement and exploitation of Africans for labor and capital gain. The documentary describes how the British’s development of the transatlantic slave trade for colonial America served as the catalyst for racism, not the reverse. As Professor James Walvin, Professor of History Emeritus at the University of YorkRead More Capital Punishment Essay - Physician Participation in the Death Penalty2644 Wo rds   |  11 PagesThe evidence on deterrence is doubtful at best. On the one hand, statistics do not indicate the existence of a significant deterrent effect. A United Nations committee studying capital punishment found that the data which now exist show no correlation between the existence of capital punishment and lower rates of capital crime. On the other hand, however, there is significant question as to whether statistics can be expected to show the deterrent effects of the death penalty. We partly know whoRead MoreLeading Ethical Theories Of Ethics1891 Words   |  8 PagesLeading Ethical Theories Consequentialism Deontology Virtue Theory example Mill s utilitarianism Kantian ethics Aristotle s moral theory abstract description An action is right if it promotes the best consequences. An action is right if it is in accordance with a moral rule or principle. An action is right if it is what a virtuous agent would do in the circumstances. more concrete specification The best consequences are those in which happiness is maximized. A moral rule is one that is requiredRead MoreNormative Theories Of Ethics And Its Principles2769 Words   |  12 Pagesaction is moral? v) What, in particular, determines that an individual is moral? vi) What purpose do ethics serve? vii) How do human beings acquire moral knowledge? viii) Why should human beings be moral? (Deveaux, 2009). In the words of John Stuart Mill, Utilitarianism â€Å"From the dawn of philosophy, the question concerning the summum bonum, or, what is the same thing, concerning the foundation of morality, has been accounted the main problem in speculative thought†¦Ã¢â‚¬  A relativistic normative theoryRead MoreEssay on Rights and Voluntary Euthanasia3662 Words   |  15 Pagesconsequences? One popular answer is the one given by John Stuart Mill in his famous essay, Utilitarianism good consequences are simply happiness, and happiness is pleasure and freedom from pain - not only physical pain but also distress of other kinds. According to this view, then, the right action is that which produces the most pleasure and least pain for all those affected. Another kind of answer is also found in the works of Mill, notably in his Essay on Liberty but also in Utilitarianism: theRead MoreEssay on the Role of Women in Ancient Greece14417 Words   |  58 Pagesneighboring land and people, which fun damentally changed the marginal products of Spartan men’s and Spartan women’s labor. To exploit the potential gains from a reallocation of labor—specifically, to provide the appropriate incentives and the proper human capital formation—men granted women property (and other) rights. Consistent with our explanation for the rise of women’s rights, when Sparta lost the conquered land several centuries later, the rights for women disappeared. Two conclusions emerge that mayRead MoreIwc1 Literature, Arts and Humanities Essay10028 Words   |  41 PagesDonatello was a sculptor. The other figures are authors. Question 8: Multiple Choice This philosopher is best known for his argument that a life guided by reason and virtue would lead to happiness. a) Aristotle b) Confucius c) Epicurus d) Democritus Feedback: The correct answer is a. Aristotle is best known for for his argument that a life guided by reason and virtue would lead to happiness. Question 9: Multiple Choice An art technique that uses realistic imagery to create the illusion ofRead MoreHistory of Work Ethic8363 Words   |  34 Pagesbetter than work appropriate for slaves. Hard work, whether due to economic need or under the orders of a master, was disdained. It was recognized that work was necessary for the satisfaction of material needs, but philosophers such as Plato and Aristotle made it clear that the purpose for which the majority of men labored was in order that the minority, the à ©lite, might engage in pure exercises of the mind--art, philosophy, and politics (Tilgher, 1930, p. 5). Plato recognized the notion of a divisionRead Moreethical decision making16006 Words   |  65 Pagescharacter, that person will behave ethically as a matter of course. Virtue ethics is based on the writings of the Greek philosopher Aristotle (384–382 bce). Aristotle (1975) believed that there was general agreement that everyone has a â€Å"life goal† and that ultimate life goal was â€Å"happiness.† Although each person has a different deï ¬ nition of happiness, Aristotle believed that happiness is achieved by what he called â€Å"excellence in performing rational activities† (thinking), which includes â€Å"excellence